Ray, like the moodiness and shadows of the first one.
I must say also Ray, I like the bottle you keep your aftershave in
Onyx, rare we disagree but we do on this one. For a product shoot, where we wanted to see the product this lighting would be unacceptable. For a still life, it's great. Remember most still life is a development of still life paintings from the great masters who usually had the light of a window to the side, even then it was hazy european sun, not clear aussie light.