Page 1 of 1

Wedding shots for Critique

PostPosted: Sun Dec 09, 2007 9:19 pm
by W00DY
Hi All,

These were taken at my cousins wedding. I was just a guest and made sure I kept right out of the pro's way. Would love your thoughts.

#1
Image


#2
Image


#3
Image


:D

PostPosted: Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:14 am
by scottvd
So the title under my name is "newbie" - I feel like a special ed kid critiquing a PhD on his quantum-physics lecture.. That being said here's my unwarranted, I've owned a DSLR for two whole months now, never taken a wedding photo in my life before, opinions.. (:

#1 is my favorite but think a bit of fill light would be more flattering.

#2 background is a bit pronounced, and although I don't know what would do it (contrast, or something?) the dress could be a bit whiter - looks a bit too blended in tone with her flesh (unlike #1).

#3 crop is too narrow for me - too much headroom - I think the bystanders are needed to more appropriately set the scene and wouldn't be distracting. Perhaps groom could be dodged a bit..

HA.. I *so* don't know what I'm talking about but that was fun!

~(:

`S

PostPosted: Mon Dec 10, 2007 10:44 am
by PiroStitch
Exposure wise, all 3 are great. I think #2 would benefit from a bit more contrast by adjusting the levels so the couple stands out a bit more but not too much.

Did you take successive shots of #3? The only thing about it is the bride's expression. It's candid, maybe cute but she might be a bit upset about her upturned nose. It's out of your control but usually when someone is walking or laughing, I try to take multiple shots to make the candid shots more pleasing as well.

PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:35 am
by W00DY
scottvd wrote:
#1 is my favorite but think a bit of fill light would be more flattering.



This is one of my favourites as well, I love her expression

scottvd wrote:
#2 background is a bit pronounced, and although I don't know what would do it (contrast, or something?) the dress could be a bit whiter - looks a bit too blended in tone with her flesh (unlike #1).



I'll try a few things and see what happens. I actually desaturated this and then applied a very light red hue to it, that woudl explain the white dress issue. Maybe the tinging doesn't work?

scottvd wrote:
#3 crop is too narrow for me - too much headroom - I think the bystanders are needed to more appropriately set the scene and wouldn't be distracting. Perhaps groom could be dodged a bit..



I know... problem is there was a tripod setup in the aisle and as I was also sitting (and only had the one lens) I didn't have much choice but to get the tripod legs in, so I cropped them out :lol: and yes, the grooms head is a little blown on top!!!

Thanks for the comments Scott, much appreciated.

PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:42 am
by W00DY
PiroStitch wrote:
Exposure wise, all 3 are great.



Thanks, I love the S5 :D

PiroStitch wrote:
I think #2 would benefit from a bit more contrast by adjusting the levels so the couple stands out a bit more but not too much.



I'll give this a go and post the results

PiroStitch wrote:
Did you take successive shots of #3? The only thing about it is the bride's expression. It's candid, maybe cute but she might be a bit upset about her upturned nose. It's out of your control but usually when someone is walking or laughing, I try to take multiple shots to make the candid shots more pleasing as well.


Yeah, I see your point. As mentioned I was in a difficult position with this one. I did take a few more but they were not quite as good as this one (I felt). Luckily the bride (my cousin) is used to her little nose and does find it cute :lol:

Thanks for the comments mate, appreciate them.

:D