Thanks for the comments folks. The second one should have been the winner but it looks like it ended up with a bit of motion blur in the foreground which spoilt it a bit and as Xerebus has noted there is also what looks like might be some lens flare in there as well. I didn't notice it until I had printed the shot big
.
The last shot is in colour not B&W as has been suggested infact I boosted the saturation a bit to try and bring out the foreground rocks.
Anyway thanks for the feedback