DSLRUsers.com

The access to these rocks is pretty treacherous

Which one of these should I print?

#2 is amazing! Did you use fill flash in #3, I think it looks much better without (on my screen anyway! )

I like the composition in #1, but the drama in the sky in the last two! Great spot you've discovered though, looks like hours of fun..

You could print all of them, but I like the second best. I can give you no reason for it. I just like it!

I prefer #1 - more focus on the nice slippery rocks.

Bob, i like them all but 1 & 3 are nice but is that a dust bunny that appears in both these pics to the left in the clouds? Or is just the edge of a cloud as it is not in #2.

Cheers
John
BBJ

I like the 3rd pic as it has more brightness on the mossy rocks.

#3 for me as there's a better balance between rocks and sky. #2 leaves me thinking that it should have been taken a bit lower to the rocks, which you've done with #3.

#1 doesn't provide enough drama in the clouds compared to the other 2.

#1 is #1

I have just printed all 3 of these @ 24" x 16" (25 x 17 paper size).
I had agreed with the main thrust of opinion of responses in this thread until after I viewed the prints.

From the prints:-
#3 wins by a fair margin because of the sky and the color of the green moss prints better.

#1 has good depth to it and the extra concentration of mossy rock area adds interest

#2 is not far behind but just doesn't afford the impact of the others.

Interesting!