ATJ wrote:Steve,
I like the third one best. You have given the Tubastraea are really nice 3D effect, even showing some of the fluorescence. The goby is lit well and has a lot of detail.
The batfish sunbusrt is well executed, but don't like the ones chopped in half, leaving the frame. If you have to chop any of them, I'd prefer them coming into the frame and have their faces visible.
The lizard fish has a lot of detail but its colours sort of disappear into the background (more the fish's fault than yours).
Thanks for the detailed feedback ATJ. It was a shame I chopped the faces off those bat fish, but im still happy with the image. Those fish actually moved quite quickly and were prone to swimming/tilting away from the camera. Annoying!