Page 1 of 1

Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 5:28 pm
by Remorhaz
I'd long wanted to try creating a stacked star trails image but the light pollution in the city makes this a difficult proposition. My brother in law owns a farm in central New South Wales (out near Dubbo) and we visited for a few days during the Easter school holidays. Since we were staying on the farm I was hoping the opportunity to try some star trails would present itself.

Firstly what are Star Trails - in essence they are streaks of light left behind on the sensor or film from the stars as they travel across the sky in front of an open camera shutter. In fact, it only seems this way - in reality the stars are stationary and it's the rotation of the earth that makes them appear to streak and spin.

... OK first the end result in all it's glory... would love any feedback/suggestions/etc...

Image

Technical Details:
Nikon D7000 + Tokina 12-24mm f/4.0 Lens @ 12 mm
Twilight Image: 58 seconds at f/11, ISO 100
Star Trails Images: 210 x 60 second exposures (3.5 hours) at f/4.0, ISO 1250

For good star trails you need a couple environmental conditions:

- clear skies (clouds obscure the stars)
- minimal light pollution (lights from the ground shining up into the sky washing out all but the brightest stars - cities are bad)
- minimal moon (anything above about a quarter moon will both light the sky and obscure the stars (and overexpose the frame if it includes the moon))

As luck would have it the first night we were on the farm met these conditions - which was lucky since the nights which followed did not (very very cloudy).

We'd been driving for half the day to get there and we arrived late in the afternoon and by the time we got settled I only had a very short time to find a suitable location close to the farmhouse (within a few minutes walk) and setup my tripod before sunset.

I knew if I wanted to have the trails appear as a circular pattern around a central point in the sky I'd need to point roughly south (actually they spin around the Southern Celestial Pole (in the southern hemisphere)). So I found this old dead tree which would provide my foreground interest. Then I fired up an IOS (iPhone/iPad) app called SkySafari on my iPad so I could locate where Sigma Octantis (the closest thing to the southern pole star) was going to be in the sky and arranged the composition appropriately.

What do you need to take star trails:

- a camera (with the ability to specify manual settings and ideally with the ability to select a bulb mode for long exposures)
- a sturdy tripod
- a remote cable release (with an intervalometer function)
- you may want to keep the lens warm and protected to prevent dew formation (lens hood and I used some woollen socks wrapped around the lens)
- enough battery power (single large battery, spare batteries or battery grip) to last the desired number of frames (remember that batteries last less in the cold)
- a large enough memory card to hold all the images
- software to stack the resulting images (Photoshop, Startrails.de, DeepSkyStacker, StarStax, etc)

What is the technique/camera settings:

- lock your camera down on a tripod (I used a sand bag hanging from the centre column hook to weigh it down)
- set manual focus for the scene (on the foreground interest or about a third the way into the scene)
- take a suitable twilight image (this will form the basis of the non sky components of your final image) using normal landscape settings (aperture stopped down, low ISO, grad filters, etc)
- do not move the camera - change to star capturing settings:
- do NOT change focus
- put the camera in bulb mode
- wide open aperture (in my case it was f/4)
- higher ISO (I used ISO 1250) - aperture and ISO determine exposure for stars only
- daylight white balance
- select an appropriate shutter speed (in my case it was 60 seconds but something in the range of 30 to 120 seconds is likely the go) - shutter controls the ambient exposure - don't overexpose the sky or any light pollution
- setup the intervalometer to take the number of continuous frames you need (in my case 60 second exposures with a one second interval between them)
- if you want lots of circles in the image you'll need at least two and a half hours worth of images (in my case I had three and a half hours worth)
- start the sequence once the sky is completely dark

Once I'd started the star captures I actually left the camera in the paddock and went back to the farmhouse to wait it out in more comfort. My only concern was that some of the bulls might come over to where I'd put the tripod and knock it or worse still trample the camera, but the camera gods must have been smiling on me that night and all was good when I checked after the first hour and a half and then again at the end after three and a half hours.

What I hadn't realised at the time was the town over the hills in the distance which was almost under the celestial pole which polluted the sky just above the horizon and also the highway over the ridge line in the distance which every now and then had headlights pointing my way - this all required a bit of post processing to fix (which I had to learn :)). Still I was very happy with the end result for my first attempt.

Also after I'd finished shooting the star trail interval shots I took some dark frame images (which I didn't end up using) and I also took some single shot images of the stars in the sky.

To do this you basically just frame a composition pointing the camera up into the sky and use camera settings like:

- wide open aperture (in my case it was f/4)
- higher ISO (I used ISO 2500) - enough to expose the stars
- select an appropriate shutter speed - in this case you want a shutter speed slow enough to not have motion blur of the stars moving in the sky - the value is actually a factor of
- lens focal length (the longer the focal length the shorter the shutter needs to be since the relative motion of the stars is increased)
- direction you're pointing at (the stars "move" slower closer to the celestial pole and faster further away)
- in my case I chose 25 seconds (but 15-30 seconds would be a good starting point)

Image

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 6:34 pm
by PiroStitch
Fantastic! Even with a how to and a back story which is even better :)

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 8:55 pm
by biggerry
awesome shot rodney, can barely notice the light pollution from the town.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 9:53 pm
by surenj
looking fantastic! Very cool how you've captured the individual star colors as well!

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 10:36 pm
by Mr Darcy
Great job!
When I have done star trails I have simply opened the shutter for an hour or two, but that makes light pollution very hard to control.

Can you give a detailed explanation of the stacking process?
I vaguely recall BigV explaining this once before, but I also remember not being able to understand it.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Fri Apr 20, 2012 11:11 pm
by colin_12
Really good effort here Rodney. :up:
Next time you need to stay out with the gear though......woose. :lol:

Nice to see the inclusion of some sad trees to give interest etc.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 8:57 am
by Remorhaz
PiroStitch wrote:Fantastic! Even with a how to and a back story which is even better :)


Thanks Piro :)

biggerry wrote:awesome shot rodney, can barely notice the light pollution from the town.


Ah yes - the power of Photoshop (I actually had to go out of Lightroom for once - aghast!!!). There was very little polution in the sky (it's not a very big town) but just above the horizon was lit which I "fixed" when blending the twilight and other images

surenj wrote:looking fantastic! Very cool how you've captured the individual star colors as well!


Yes it was surprising the different colours at first but I guess it makes sense - we have a yellow sun but out there there are suns at all different stages of development (red, blue, etc)

... Sorry Greg - have to go (pick up my children from the country) - but will post up the details for stacking later today :)

Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 10:04 am
by tasadam
Interesting image, and a very detailed explanation, thank you, I'm sure many will learn from it.

One thing, don't give up if there is a moon out, you just need to find a way to utilize its light...

http://www.redbubble.com/people/tasadam ... h-tasmania

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 11:41 am
by surenj
Remorhaz wrote:Yes it was surprising the different colours at first but I guess it makes sense - we have a yellow sun but out there there are suns at all different stages of development (red, blue, etc)

I guess I was hinting that the color pickup at such high ISO is quite neat. Not sure whether my sensor would stand up against that. I didn't get much color from the milky way without massive vibrance adjustments last time (first time) I tried.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 12:47 pm
by aim54x
Good stuff!

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 2:30 pm
by sevencolours
Rodney

that is a great image

and thank you for the detailed description of how you put it all together.
Makes me want to try one.

It is also about different eras: way before iphones and ipads:

I learned to find the South Pole, so i would not get lost, by this method:

Draw a line down the long axis of the Southern Cross.
Draw a line between the two pointers Alpha and Beta Centauri. Divide this line in half and draw the perpendicular bisector line
where they meet is the South Pole

It is close to the South pole, not as close as your method of using Sigma Octantis, but good enough to find your way.

Philip

Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 2:35 pm
by tasadam
If you can't see the pointers, try roughly 6 times the long axis of the southern cross (under it), then straight down from that point.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 4:53 pm
by CraigVTR
Great shots and a great explanation. I must get off my backside and go out and try this one night when I do not have to work. :up:

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Sat Apr 21, 2012 5:27 pm
by Remorhaz
Mr Darcy wrote:Great job! When I have done star trails I have simply opened the shutter for an hour or two, but that makes light pollution very hard to control. Can you give a detailed explanation of the stacking process?


Thanks Greg - and here you go I've written it up... :)

Stacking the Images in Photoshop:

You can use Adobe Photoshop to stack your resulting images to create the main star trail image. The method for doing this is...

- Open Photoshop
- Go to Files -> Scripts -> Load Files into Stack...
- Do not tick the Attempt to Automatically Align Source Images box - the stars are often the dominant feature in these images so it may rotate all the images to make the stars line up and you'll get no trails
- The files will load into a stack, each on a separate Layer
- Select the first image and set the Layer Blend mode to Lighten
- Right click that layer and select Copy Layer Style
- Click the second layer then shift click the last layer (selecting all the layers)
- Right click and select Paste Layer Style (this will set the Blend mode to Lighten for all layers)
- Flatten the image and Save it
- NB: When you stack a few hundred frames noise will also be eliminated
- NB: I did no PP at all to the NEFs before stacking (set the WB before starting to shoot the trails)

There are other ways to stack but this pretty fast (NB: there are Photoshop Actions you can download which automate this but there really isn't much to it doing it manually). There's also a method where every now and then you use Screen as the Layer Blend mode.

Stacking huge numbers of images will tax your computer and photoshop (because all the individual images are loaded into separate layers creating an enormous photoshop document). Stacking speed will depend on the size of your individual frames, the amount of RAM you have and the speed of your drive(s). I suggest stacking sub stacks of your images (with perhaps somewhere between 30 and 100 of your images at a time) flatten and save each sub stack and then stack all the resultant sub stacks at the end.

FYI: I started with stacking 40 images (as suggested by someone else with a Windows laptop with Core i7, 8GB RAM and SSD drive) and had no problems. I have a newish Macbook Pro (Core i7, 8GB RAM and SSD) and I ended up stacking over 100 Nikon D7000 NEFs (20MB each) at a time with no problems - perhaps Mac OSX is more efficient with this. NB: If you stack too many images and your machine starts paging/swapping to disk to cope with the virtual memory requirements your stacking time will go from 60 seconds to potentially hours.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Mon Apr 23, 2012 2:03 am
by surenj
Thanks for the extra info! It would be great to try this technique one day.

#2 - I only noticed the silhouette now. Very subtle. Nice.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Mon Apr 23, 2012 7:47 am
by Mr Darcy
Thanks heaps for that info Rodney.

Now all I need is a clear dark night. And to be free for the night. That tends to be our busiest time. :roll:

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Tue Apr 24, 2012 7:21 am
by Remorhaz
surenj wrote:Thanks for the extra info! It would be great to try this technique one day.


I still want to try that city based star trails (either in the city (e.g. SOH) or from the north side of the harbour (so we get the centre of the trails)

#2 - I only noticed the silhouette now. Very subtle. Nice.


:) - hard to see the black silhouette against the blackish sky :) pretty hard to compose as well - needed a third hand to wave a torch about :)

Mr Darcy wrote:Thanks heaps for that info Rodney.
Now all I need is a clear dark night. And to be free for the night. That tends to be our busiest time


Good luck :)

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Tue Apr 24, 2012 7:17 pm
by zafra52
Now, that is a superb picture! It goes to
prove the earth rotates - or is it the other
way around? I always knew the earth was
flat and the Sun, Moon and the star rotated
around it!
:D

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Tue Apr 24, 2012 8:47 pm
by Mr Darcy
zafra52 wrote: the star

Only one?
Must be Brad Pitt.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Tue Apr 24, 2012 9:25 pm
by surenj
Mr Darcy wrote:Only one?
Must be Brad Pitt.

I doubt it. All news sources state that he rotates on his own axis.

Re: Star Trails over Central NSW - My First Startrails Attempt..

PostPosted: Thu Apr 26, 2012 7:17 pm
by Remorhaz
... and here is a timelapse movie created from the star trails source frames:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oMWZ6YIjIgg