W00DY wrote:Firstly - I hope we are all not going down the path of "we will not answer your question if it has been discussed before". You all realise this is going to get worse the more the forum grows.
Woody I'd hope not either (even though I'm firmly in the look elsewhere responses above). Here's my take on the "look elsewhere" issue:
- If I'm aware of a thread that pretty exhaustively covers the topic I'll track it down and post a link to that thread.
- If someone's a newb I'll also point out the search tool for the future and explain why it's useful (cuts down on cross posts, consolidates in one place etc)
- If I'm unaware of another thread on the topic I'll post in the current one (ie I don't go searching for a thread that answers a post before I post a reply
- I will NEVER say something as bald as "if you'd only done a search first you'd find your answer" since that helps no-one
Woody wrote:Secondly - I honestly had not seen much discussion (other than the ones I have initiated within "tripod" threads) regarding monopods.
That's fine - it's not possible to read and recall every thread - hence the thrust of the post I made I guess (which was intended as a poke in the ribs and if taken otherwise I apologise)
Woody wrote:I was simply trying to get a monopod thread up rather then hide some info within a tripod thread.
I think your idea of getting a monopod thread only is a good one, but maybe what we need do is to consolidate some of these sorts of details from the existing threads into a new one in the absolute beginners section (or maybe even a new
FAQ section?). To that end I have over the last few weeks been collecting together tips & hints from various threads for a consolidated posting. I think something like this for popular topics like monopods, tripods, heads, lenses & the like might go a long way towards cutting down cross posting since, the info would all be neat and in one place.
Woody wrote:I would suggest that if people don't have anything useful to say other than "do a search" than don't post at all.
Well put and I agree (but I'll still relapse occasionally and make a comment like I did above)
Woody wrote:I for one will try an answer any questions that are posted regardless if they have been discussed before. That is the nature of a friendly community.
Exactly and that's to be encouraged.
Woody wrote:Sorry if this sounds harsh, rude, stupid whatever but this issue has been getting worse lately and is only going to increase as the forum grows.
I don't think this either harsh or rude. I think it is honest and you have a right to make your opinion known. That's what we all treasure about the forum.
Woody wrote:Amins feel free to close this thread if you don't think it is a valid discussion.
Hmmm.. How do you define what's valid. Nothing wrong with a healthy debate. I'd hope the admins DON'T see a need to close the thread.
Sorry for the long post, but I agree with you that this is an important issue.