Page 1 of 1
Please Explain
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:38 pmby mic
If in the future I happen to get a D200 or D2X or D2hs
My 17-55 DX Lens won't Feng Shui with them ?
Thanks,
Mic.
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:43 pmby MATT
errr Ok Mic please explain???
I believe the DX will only work properly with a non full frame camera.
Could be wrong
MATT
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:46 pmby mic
So Matt,
The D70 is 1.5 Crop Factor right ? which the 17-55 works well with being DX ?
The others are full frame so there is none of this multiplying stuff going on right ?
Mic.
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:54 pmby MATT
Thats what I believe,
But I think the Dx lens on a full frame give CA on the fringes cause of there design for the crop factor.
My kit lens 18-70DX in the info that came with says that it is not compatible with my F65 film camera for this reason.
As such I have only purchased non DX lenes(50 1.8 and 24-120VR).
The was some descussion on this board about off loading DX lenses before the D200 is released with its full frame.
Not sure on the D2X either I had a feeling it had the crop factor type sensor.
I'm sure someone will pop in with a definitive answer.
CHeers
MATT
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:58 pmby PiroStitch
Mic,
with the quality of pics you're taking, dont' worry too much because by the time the D200 or a ff cam is released by Nikon, you'll have enough $$ to get a replacement.
Also to offset the cost, you can palm the 17-55 to one of us chumps who can't afford it yet
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:59 pmby gstark
Mick,
There are, at this time, no full frame Nikon DSLRs, either in production, or proposed.
Each of your DX lenses will fit all current and announced (as at today) Nikon DSLR cameras.
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 5:59 pmby MHD
All Nikon DSLRs to date are cropped (known as DX or APS sized) sensors
A 17-55/2.8 DX will perform wonderfully on a D2X
however, due to thier smaller circle size, DX lenses will not perform well at all on a full frame camera. If and when Nikon produce one is pure speculation
That said, if it were my choice, I would save a few more pennies and go for the 28-80/2.8 as it is a wonderfull wonderfull lens
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 6:02 pmby mic
Thanks Matt,
Hee hhee Wayne,
I think I have some way to go yet.
So if I use the 17-55 on a full frame camera it will have fringing ?
All the time, like at wide or zoom ?
Posted:
Wed Sep 21, 2005 6:05 pmby mic
Arrrrrrrhhhhhh
Thanks Gary & MHD, I just had tummy troubles thinking my 17-55 might not go well with a D2X Feeeeeeeuuuuuuwwwwwwwwww
Mic.